... well, each pot is it's own little "ecosystem", and can drift off track even if a pot right next to it is fine,... many influencing factors in-pot! And organics are no panacea against off pH once in the pot, despite what all the BS arm-flapping about that is out there,... I see off pH organic fed potted plants all-the-time here,....it's just less likely because of the mildness of them,, but the soil herd plays a huge role in all this!
That probe is dubious, yes, but it's close enough here to confirm the pot is too acidic,.. give it a flush, starting with 2x the pot volume of clear water,.. what's your water source? the pH and hardness are key factors here on determining if you need to adjust it, or add Ca-Mg,... do you have a good pH meter, calibrated and accurate? You'll need to check the pH of the run-off about half way through to see where you're at, and figure when it's enough,... the last pour should have a mild dose of nutes in it, to avoid triggering a potential nute defc. snafu,....