Im using a 2 gallon dwc bucket and doing ok its just more work changing out the water and keeping the PH balanced because the plant sucks up a lot of water. It depends on how big of an area you have to grow in my box is 20"x 20" x 4' so my height is limited therefore I needed to use a shorter bucket if you got the height I would use a 5 gallon bucket more volume of water is always better. This is mine at 37 days