hey peanut8!
I think it depend alot also on the ambient temperature outside the tent.
Personalty i had a 400w HPS with standard reflector in a 60x60x140 tent and i did run into temperature problems so i got a 125mm cool-tube and it has made my temp drop by 4 degrees Celsius.
but as i said, my outside temp are around 20 degrees Celsius so the air going into the tent is already decently warm so for me the cool-tube was a must, especially when the plants got taller and closer to the light. but if you are bringing in cooler air temperatures and have good air circulation and extraction i'm sure you could do without a cool-tube.
also by installing a cool-tube i was able to lower the light closer to the canopy of the plants, that helped getting more light to the lower budding sites in my slightly over crowed tent.
hope this helped you in one way or another.
peace,
trustfullytasty