Not trying to answer for TIna but 3 of any light are going to have a much bigger footprint than any single light. LEDs are usually focused tightly so distance from the source is a much bigger issue than HPS which sends it's light equally around in every direction.
Watt for watt most LEDs are going to have about the same efficiency. The difference lies in the diodes themselves; the higher quality the diode the more lumens per watt than a lower quality LED.

Watt for watt most LEDs are going to have about the same efficiency. The difference lies in the diodes themselves; the higher quality the diode the more lumens per watt than a lower quality LED.
