Grow Room GROW BAGS : To Be Or Not To Be ??

Joined
Aug 6, 2018
Messages
70
Reputation
0
Reaction score
122
Points
0
Hiya,

I had intended on using 5 gallons plastic buckets w/ holes drilled round the bottom.
My grow room will be warm most of the time.
Maybe 74 F to 86 F in the summer.

Amazon product ASIN B013JFHMNK
I see folks using these bags.
Is this what I need or what??

(Yes, I am ignorant.)

Thanks in advance.
 
Will, I'm planning on using these same bags for my first grow, I'm also interested in hearing what the experienced folks here think of them.
 
Consider Air-Pots, associated with increased root growth and presumably higher yields, and also providing considerable benefit from being rigid, media not shifting and tearing roots as moved around, the pot and its medium slightly elevated, not sitting on the ground (can't be good for roots); etc.
 
I read the air pots dry out really quick in hot room though....
 
The cloth pots breath pretty well, so they will dry out faster than regular plastic or clay pots. But the air pots do dry even a little bit faster in my experience. They are a little more open to direct outside air than the fabric, so makes sense. Fabric pots still do the root pruning when they hit the air at the edges, though not as efficiently as the airpots. I have seen the occasional root start to twist back a little, and they do spread on the bottom of the fabric pots where there's not so much air a little.

Fabric pots typically (though not all models) have handles on them, so are a little easier to move around.

Also make sure and think about how you plan on watering and what you would like to happen with the run off. The fabric pots sit directly on the ground, usually in a tray to catch run off, and will absorb back up into the pot and into the soil the run off as the soil dries back out. Airpots have a small space between the soil and the ground to keep their air pruning going all the way around and underneath, so water that runs off will be stuck just evaporating.

Both are easy to clean and reuse, though I'd have to say the plastic is a little easier if you're OCD about getting them squeaky clean. Probably a limit to how many times the fabric can be cleaned out and re-used before it starts to deteriorate and the seams start to fall apart, but I haven't hit it yet.

Personally, I preferred the fabric when I was growing just a little bit over the airpots, but sure there are plenty around that would lean the other way. :greenthumb:
 
The cloth pots breath pretty well, so they will dry out faster than regular plastic or clay pots. But the air pots do dry even a little bit faster in my experience. They are a little more open to direct outside air than the fabric, so makes sense. Fabric pots still do the root pruning when they hit the air at the edges, though not as efficiently as the airpots. I have seen the occasional root start to twist back a little, and they do spread on the bottom of the fabric pots where there's not so much air a little.

Fabric pots typically (though not all models) have handles on them, so are a little easier to move around.

Also make sure and think about how you plan on watering and what you would like to happen with the run off. The fabric pots sit directly on the ground, usually in a tray to catch run off, and will absorb back up into the pot and into the soil the run off as the soil dries back out. Airpots have a small space between the soil and the ground to keep their air pruning going all the way around and underneath, so water that runs off will be stuck just evaporating.

Both are easy to clean and reuse, though I'd have to say the plastic is a little easier if you're OCD about getting them squeaky clean. Probably a limit to how many times the fabric can be cleaned out and re-used before it starts to deteriorate and the seams start to fall apart, but I haven't hit it yet.

Personally, I preferred the fabric when I was growing just a little bit over the airpots, but sure there are plenty around that would lean the other way. :greenthumb:
Thanks for the info.

Is there a big advantage to the bags over a regular 5 gallon bucket with drain holes?
Buckets I got.
 
Thanks for the info.

Is there a big advantage to the bags over a regular 5 gallon bucket with drain holes?
Buckets I got.
Breathable bags, Air-Pots, etc., all other things being equal, should support higher yields and maybe even quality vs. drilling some holes in a bucket. The amount of media/soil aeration is higher. This is probably the main reason most users prefer these over simple bucket-type pots/containers.

Have you ever considered hempy buckets? I tried this a few times and the plants came out much the same (size, etc.) as those grown in Air-Pots, but others get better results.
 
I never grew anything much in buckets to be able to compare, but put enough holes in one and I don't see why it wouldn't work. Might dry out slower than the fabric pots. I like the fast drying...think it helped me be less prone to over watering (cannabis does like it's dry cycle). No reason why you couldn't take a smaller drill bit and go crazy all around the sides up a ways as well and make them very airpot like and see how that works for ya'.

images
 
Nah, I can get the bags.
Just didn't know if my room was going to dry them out too fast.
Anything for a better grow....
I might even get naked and dance under the moon.
 
Back
Top