Lighting Leds do not cause deficiencies! Article inside..

Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
601
Reputation
10
Reaction score
2,056
Points
0
This is under the FAQ at blackdog led, which so happens where I bought my light.. so I been hearing alot of people saying leds can cause a cal/mag deficiency so I'll paste this here and see what ya'll think.. correct me if I'm wrong I just don't see how light could give a difficiency , (soil obviously yes if your soil is low in nutrients) unless there is a proven scientific fact ya'll can let me know about. Knowledge is key..

No, LED lights do not cause any kind of nutrient deficiency.

A rumor was started that LED lights cause magnesium deficiency when people noticed that some plants develop purple petioles (leaf stalks) or streaks on the stems under LED lights, but not under HPS lights. While purple coloration on stems and petioles can be one of the signs of magnesium deficiency, it is also a sign that the plant is producing natural purple pigments (anthocyanin) in response to ultraviolet (UV) light. Many artificial lights (including HPS and most LEDs) don't give off UV light, so plants grown under these lights don't produce this natural pigmentation. Under these UV-lacking lights, purple coloration is often a sign of magnesium deficiency. However, when grown under UV-containing Black Dog LED lights or natural sunlight, plants will produce their full range of natural pigmentation-- it is not necessarily a sign of a nutrient deficiency.

The major symptom of magnesium deficiency is usually yellowing, blotchy-looking (chlorotic) leaves, accompanied by purple stems and petioles. When growing under Black Dog LED grow lights, unless the leaves are chlorotic, purple stems and petioles are not a sign of a magnesium deficiency-- they are a sign of a happy, healthy plant.
 
Last edited:
This is under the FAQ at blackdog led, which so happens where I bought my light.. so I been hearing alot of people saying leds can cause a cal/mag deficiency so I'll paste this here and see what ya'll think.. correct me if I'm wrong I just don't see how light could give a difficiency , (soil obviously yes if your soil is low in nutrients) unless there is a proven scientific fact ya'll can let me know about. Knowledge is key..

No, LED lights do not cause any kind of nutrient deficiency.

A rumor was started that LED lights cause magnesium deficiency when people noticed that some plants develop purple petioles (leaf stalks) or streaks on the stems under LED lights, but not under HPS lights. While purple coloration on stems and petioles can be one of the signs of magnesium deficiency, it is also a sign that the plant is producing natural purple pigments (anthocyanin) in response to ultraviolet (UV) light. Many artificial lights (including HPS and most LEDs) don't give off UV light, so plants grown under these lights don't produce this natural pigmentation. Under these UV-lacking lights, purple coloration is often a sign of magnesium deficiency. However, when grown under UV-containing Black Dog LED lights or natural sunlight, plants will produce their full range of natural pigmentation-- it is not necessarily a sign of a nutrient deficiency.

The major symptom of magnesium deficiency is usually yellowing, blotchy-looking (chlorotic) leaves, accompanied by purple stems and petioles. When growing under Black Dog LED grow lights, unless the leaves are chlorotic, purple stems and petioles are not a sign of a magnesium deficiency-- they are a sign of a happy, healthy plant.

the second part is the most important, no one here says they have a calmag problem due to purple stems, that is actually indicative of a P def more than Mg. The reason that LED's DO cause calmag def is because of the photon initiated hormones that affect the nutrient uptake, this is just something they are trying to sound smart about so people will buy their product. It is just an advertising gimmick, LED's def cause calmag def
 
This is under the FAQ at blackdog led, which so happens where I bought my light.. so I been hearing alot of people saying leds can cause a cal/mag deficiency so I'll paste this here and see what ya'll think.. correct me if I'm wrong I just don't see how light could give a difficiency , (soil obviously yes if your soil is low in nutrients) unless there is a proven scientific fact ya'll can let me know about. Knowledge is key..

No, LED lights do not cause any kind of nutrient deficiency.

A rumor was started that LED lights cause magnesium deficiency when people noticed that some plants develop purple petioles (leaf stalks) or streaks on the stems under LED lights, but not under HPS lights. While purple coloration on stems and petioles can be one of the signs of magnesium deficiency, it is also a sign that the plant is producing natural purple pigments (anthocyanin) in response to ultraviolet (UV) light. Many artificial lights (including HPS and most LEDs) don't give off UV light, so plants grown under these lights don't produce this natural pigmentation. Under these UV-lacking lights, purple coloration is often a sign of magnesium deficiency. However, when grown under UV-containing Black Dog LED lights or natural sunlight, plants will produce their full range of natural pigmentation-- it is not necessarily a sign of a nutrient deficiency.

The major symptom of magnesium deficiency is usually yellowing, blotchy-looking (chlorotic) leaves, accompanied by purple stems and petioles. When growing under Black Dog LED grow lights, unless the leaves are chlorotic, purple stems and petioles are not a sign of a magnesium deficiency-- they are a sign of a happy, healthy plant.
I've had about 5 different harvests with led lights and I've never had deficiencies. Only thing you have to watch for is overwatering as the soil takes longer to dry out, they work great but they have to be solid fixtures
 
I've had about 5 different harvests with led lights and I've never had deficiencies. Only thing you have to watch for is overwatering as the soil takes longer to dry out, they work great but they have to be solid fixtures

to be fair @PureBlaze420 you know what you are doing lol, a lot of folks don't. IF I had to guess that you use calmag somewhere along the way. Also this is strain dependant for the most part, some plants have worse calmag issues than others under LED's Trust me on this one, I have done quite a bit of actual research on this topic, it is all about the photons affecting the STSD hormone, the same one that triggers the use of florigen in the plant which is the flowering hormone
 
to be fair @PureBlaze420 you know what you are doing lol, a lot of folks don't. IF I had to guess that you use calmag somewhere along the way. Also this is strain dependant for the most part, some plants have worse calmag issues than others under LED's Trust me on this one, I have done quite a bit of actual research on this topic, it is all about the photons affecting the STSD hormone, the same one that triggers the use of florigen in the plant which is the flowering hormone
I use Magnum and dont know about the rest of what your talking about but every strain is different, Dozens of Led companies out there but most are chinese pos. Check out BMLHorticulture LED's they have a bunch of comparison videos from commercial growers and a lot of information on them
 
I use Magnum and dont know about the rest of what your talking about but every strain is different, Dozens of Led companies out there but most are chinese pos. Check out BMLHorticulture LED's they have a bunch of comparison videos from commercial growers and a lot of information on them

Also I must say that I did my comparison about 6 years ago and LED tech has come a long way since then so it could be that the newer LED companies have gotten it correct with the spectrum and whatnot
 
I use Magnum and dont know about the rest of what your talking about but every strain is different, Dozens of Led companies out there but most are chinese pos. Check out BMLHorticulture LED's they have a bunch of comparison videos from commercial growers and a lot of information on them
I have used BML lights the last three grows,they are rather pricey but are worth it.My dream lamp is their Spider lamp it has a configuration of six of the lamps i currently have.My current lamps are 3 footers and are full spectrum LEDs.I have used them for the last three grows and have seen no cal mag issues.I grow with my own super soil.I currently have 5 leds.I have Advanced DS 200s x 2.I have a G8 from dorm grow,and the BMLs.I just purchased platinum P 450 today.I have not seen any cal mag issues yet.Peace
 
I have used BML lights the last three grows,they are rather pricey but are worth it.My dream lamp is their Spider lamp it has a configuration of six of the lamps i currently have.My current lamps are 3 footers and are full spectrum LEDs.I have used them for the last three grows and have seen no cal mag issues.I grow with my own super soil.I currently have 5 leds.I have Advanced DS 200s x 2.I have a G8 from dorm grow,and the BMLs.I just purchased platinum P 450 today.I have not seen any cal mag issues yet.Peace
in a few months im going to switch to spyder1200s i need ten of them but they cost $2000 each
 
Back
Top