Moon phases outdoors does it actually make a difference ?

[Non Locality]

Yet another deflection.

It's not " what gets me" it is "what I don't understand". And if it's my opinion you don't understand that's fine.

Maybe in you quest to falsify real examples of experiments concerning gravity ( surely associated with lunar phases) and plants you will. Good luck stop wasting everyone's time trying to argue with a dumb ole country boy and get to work.
Again, thank you for your contribution.

 

[Balarama]

You got me completely wrong, ole boy.
I don't want to falsify nothing, not even your opinion(we all have opinions).

The issue for me was and still is, to find connections between these studies and the original question.
When i asked you about it you went defensive and personal, so we failed to have a meaningful sort of conversation.
It's great to post studies but if they're not directly related to the topic, there will be struggle and loss of energy when trying to make sense of it.
Maybe I was expecting too much.

Thanks for taking the effort for this, but please try to explain more of it because I'm sure most people don't get these things. I correct myself, noone does.

 

[Non Locality]

The issue for me was and still is, to find connections between thesestudies and the original question. I'm not here to hold your hand.



When i asked you about it you went defensive and personal, so we failed to have ameaningful sort of conversation.
And this is the first defensive post.

All of this is pointless if we want to talk about moon phases, so off topic.
Also formalism has nothing to do about it, I'm not a philospher, i'm a physicist.
I suggest you look at a tidal curve for any day and try to make sense how it translates to gravity and plant response to it.
There is no such corellation to be observed and no philosophy can change that. Neighter can people who believe in Steiner's or other ideas on how the world works.

It's great to post studies but if they're not directly related to the topic, there will bestruggle and loss of energy when trying to make sense of it.


Your not capable of articulating how they are not related. Stop arguing if you don't like what has been said move on its that simple. If you can offer anything other than opinion do so. I did.

 

[briman]

Here is a true and tested website that has been used for a while, with everything you need to know about outdoor gardening, moon phases, astronomy, MASTER CALANDAR WITH best days and moon phases. I remember my Grandfather using the farmers almanac in a soft bound book over 40 years ago and they would send out a new copy every spring.
http://farmersalmanac.com/

Debates can get heated guys, please keep it civil and on topic. It's ok to agree to disagree. If you cant prove it, dis-prove it! Or vise versa.

 

[Balarama]

So that's exactly the point, why people use these calendars which only offer guideance without explanations how things work?
I'm not asking for holding hands, non locality but certain rules of logic have to be followed.
If you present studies, present them in a useful manner or you're mixing the muddy waters.
That's all I'll say here, spent too much time already.

 

[Non Locality]

You just won't stop will you. Again please stop hijacking the thread with your opinion about how I should present ideas. When you can't properly articulate your own. Peer reviewed research is not required here.

I presented enough information for anyone as interested as you seem to be to follow up with ON YOUR OWN. Stop being lazy.

By the way there were a number of likes to the information I volunteered. It appears it was not logical to you only. Most reasonable folks would know that then information given is way to broad to spell everything out for them in a form. Would it be respectful to write 500 page explanation? Stop being ridiculous petty, and self centered you don't like what or how I presented information, move on like the mod said.


I truly apologize to the OP.

 

[Balarama]

Whatever ole boy...whatever.

If likes were a measure for truth...

 

[Non Locality]

Lol. Here is more some truth for you. 99.7% of the all biomass on earth is plant life and yet you are waiting for empirical evidence of that has gravity has or has no effect. Plants are full of water yet no lunar phase has an affect. Lol.

 

[Balarama]

Again, your view is way too simplistic to make a valid conclusion on this topic.
And it's not funny to read at all.

Cheers

 

[Non Locality]

Again, your view is way too simplistic to make a valid conclusion on this topic.
And it's not funny to read at all.

Cheers

Again your view is only your own. Not one source provided lol. And this is a discussion forum no one is here to defend a thesis.

Why do you continue to waste everyone's time. If you are at odds with the information presented why argue? I'm not saying you are wrong. I'm saying you present nothing but unfounded arguments.

Now let's see if you can follow your own inclination... "

That's all I'll say here, spent too much time already.