Grow Mediums A-Train needs info on the coco for future run... help a brother out.

OK ... I have a question in my head that just won't go away.
If it's a dumb question, then I apologise in advance.

Here goes;

Why would anyone use clay pellets as a base in an Autopot + Airdome system?

I've seen many advocate it, but I genuinely don't understand the logic or rationale behind it.
From what very little knowledge I have, clay pellets are used to assist drainage, and also to aid in the oxygenation in systems like DWC.
I get that bit.
But what I don't get, is why you would need either in an Autopot + Airdome system.

Firstly, Autopot is essentially a leeching form of watering - it's bottom up - so why the need for a 'drainage' agent?
Top-down watering ... sure. But a bottom-up self-regulating system? Why the need for clay pellets as a drainage agent?

Secondly, why would you need clay pellets for oxygenation if you have Airdomes?
Also, most also advocate oxygenation via airstone at the reservoir ... so why the need for clay pellets for oxygenation?

If not for drainage, and not for oxygenation, then why?
How are clay pellets at the bottom of an Autopot beneficial?
What purpose do they serve?

Do people use clay pellets in their Autopot systems because of the true science behind it, as a theory?
Or is it just more about convention and its because its what other people did before them?

What am I missing?

Sorry for the dumb question ... I have been struggling with it, but just got to that point where not asking it was harder than asking it.
from what ive read up on its mainly to stop coco clogging up your air domes also the airdome and clay pebbles will be under water easier to oxygenate the water with only clay balls in than coco (it would be a soggy mess) hope that puts your mind to rest or did I just make that up :crying:
 
from what ive read up on its mainly to stop coco clogging up your air domes

Hmmm ... I wasn't aware of that being a known issue.

also the airdome and clay pebbles will be under water easier to oxygenate the water with only clay balls in than coco (it would be a soggy mess) hope that puts your mind to rest or did I just make that up :crying:

Wait.

Are we talking about Autopots with the auto-valve system?
The auto-valve is too shallow for anything to be underwater.

My understanding is that the airdome was to oxygenate the root system itself, in the pot.
I wasn't aware it was to oxygenate the water in the auto-valve.
The Airdome within the Autopot is 'taller' than the float level of the Auto-valve watering system.
 
I'd like to hear an answer about this as well, Yoz. My only guess is to avoid any sort of root rot? If that makes any sense?

I've never heard or seen root rot being a known issue in the Autopot system.
In fact, the only 'issue' I have known is when the roots love it so much, they start creeping into the Auto-valve area, which may present a risk of blockage and flooding!

But root rot?
Maybe ... anything is possible - but haven't read about it ... yet.
 
I've never heard or seen root rot being a known issue in the Autopot system.
In fact, the only 'issue' I have known is when the roots love it so much, they start creeping into the Auto-valve area, which may present a risk of blockage and flooding!

But root rot?
Maybe ... anything is possible - but haven't read about it ... yet.

Beats me, man! I'm just the guy who follows manufacturer recommendation.
 
Folks ... don't mind me.
I'm one of those annoying fuckers who always asks "why?", even when everyone has been doing it a proven way, for generations.

I have this pathological need to know the purpose of any decision to know how and why it fits into a system.
So when I see a decision to add clay pellets, by FIRST instinct is to ask "why?" ... and so far, it is a question I can't answer.

It doesn't mean an answer doesn't exist.
It just means I haven't found it yet.
Unfortunately, the way my brain is hardwired means I can't move on until that question has been answered.
its like a logical flowchart, and right now, I'm experiencing a block in the chain.

Forgive me.

... oh, and @A-Train - sorry if this hijacks your thread.
That's not my intention.
 
Hmmm ... I wasn't aware of that being a known issue.



Wait.

Are we talking about Autopots with the auto-valve system?
The auto-valve is too shallow for anything to be underwater.

My understanding is that the airdome was to oxygenate the root system itself, in the pot.
I wasn't aware it was to oxygenate the water in the auto-valve.
The Airdome within the Autopot is 'taller' than the float level of the Auto-valve watering system.
From the videos I've seen your pot always sits in water my autupot trays are about 3inches deep so your airdome is always in water I think I guess I will find out in about 3 weeks [emoji1]
 
Folks ... don't mind me.
I'm one of those annoying fuckers who always asks "why?", even when everyone has been doing it a proven way, for generations.

I have this pathological need to know the purpose of any decision to know how and why it fits into a system.
So when I see a decision to add clay pellets, by FIRST instinct is to ask "why?" ... and so far, it is a question I can't answer.

It doesn't mean an answer doesn't exist.
It just means I haven't found it yet.
Unfortunately, the way my brain is hardwired means I can't move on until that question has been answered.
its like a logical flowchart, and right now, I'm experiencing a block in the chain.

Forgive me.

... oh, and @A-Train - sorry if this hijacks your thread.
That's not my intention.

I'm the same way. QUESTION EVERYTHING. This is just one of those things that I'm just going with because it seems to be proven.
 
From the videos I've seen your pot always sits in water my autupot trays are about 3inches deep so your airdome is always in water I think I guess I will find out in about 3 weeks [emoji1]
It seems like everyone is jumping on the bandwagon go really pushing autos with a simple system. Mine is in the mail now!
 
Back
Top