Live Stoner Chat Any cigar aficionados around?

gbd

Son of the Sun.
Joined
Apr 28, 2012
Messages
2,533
Reputation
0
Reaction score
8,545
Points
0
I'm new to it and would like to pick up a sampling of smoke. What would you recommend? So far I've only sampled some fuentes- the best seller, the short story, and a few unbranded fatties. I'm getting ready to enjoy my first opus x now. At this point I have no palate for what makes a cigar good or bad so they've all been enjoyable to me. What are some of your favorites?

Cheers
 
I used to Smoke em here n There.I know ya can dip em in various Liquor's n such.Chambord is a good one.Blantons is another High end Whiskey thats popular from what I 've heard.Whiskey soaked Tobacco used to be a good Pipe smoke and a cheap cigar roll...? but tasty..:Sharing One:
 
I used to Smoke em here n There.I know ya can dip em in various Liquor's n such.Chambord is a good one.Blantons is another High end Whiskey thats popular from what I 've heard.Whiskey soaked Tobacco used to be a good Pipe smoke and a cheap cigar roll...? but tasty..:Sharing One:

Thanks for the head's up! Unfortunately I'm 'allergic' to alcohol, so those are a no-go for me. They certainly sound tasty and I'll keep them in mind to pass along to others.
 
When I first bought some cigarrs the aficionado in the store recommended me to start of with some davidoffs, somewhat "normal" cigarr, was alright, pretty mild. Went from there to a Davidoff Nicaragua which had more smell and taste to it, I enjoyed that one more.
I havn't smoked any in some time but Its down to preference, the nicaraguan was nice, I'd smoke it again :d
 
I was a hand rolled cigar smoker for many years so know a bit about them. There was a great cigar bar near where I worked that sold individual cigars, which is a great way to sample different ones to see what you like before committing to a whole box. Cigars usually contain 3 different types of tobacco, the filler, the binder and the wrapper. It's the combination of the three that gives each one it's individual taste. The green, or candola wrappers, were never to my taste. The brown, or natural wrappers are the most popular and usually give a mild flavor. My personal favorite is the madura, or black, wrapper. The taste is a bit more robust. Four countries product the majority of today's cigars, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Nicaragua and Hondorus. Cuban cigars are still banned in the US due to the Cuban embargo but I've had opportunities to smoke a few over the years. They tend to be strong and very robust. Ones from the Dominican Republic were always my favorites, with Hondorus next. Never cared much for the ones from Nicaragua. Most of the Dominican tobacco has been grown from seeds brought from Cuba and many of the Cuban manufacturers also manufacturer in the D.R. My all time favorite is the Arturo Fuente Churchill Maduro. Some others I enjoyed were Punch, CAO, H. Upmann, Macanudo (what Tony Sopranno smoked!), Hoyo de Monterrey and Partagas. For a new smoker like yourself, I would recommend the CAO or Upmann with a natural wrapper. They are milder than most of the others I've mentioned.

Cigars can get quite expensive. Mike's Cigars, http://www.mikescigars.com/brands-cigars/, sells a brand called Old Fashioned. These are seconds from some of the major manufacturers and are a lot cheaper. Most are seconds because of blemishes on the wrappers. Another good source is JR Cigars, http://www.jrcigars.com/jr/index.cfm. They are probably the biggest distributor in the country. Some of their house brands are very good and reasonably priced. I always found Mike's to be a bit cheaper on name brands than JR. Both sell sample packs which is a great way to sample different ones to find what you enjoy.

A humidor is a must have if you're serious about cigars. They will maintain them at the proper 70% relative humidity. All cigars are aged but will benefit from additional aging. Aging allows the binder, wrapper and filler to combine for a more even, flavorful smoke. Being the cheap bastard that I am, I built my own humidor from a Rubbermaid container. If you're interested I can give you the details.
 
I enjoy the Macanudo..........Nice aroma and flavor.
 
I was a hand rolled cigar smoker for many years so know a bit about them. There was a great cigar bar near where I worked that sold individual cigars, which is a great way to sample different ones to see what you like before committing to a whole box. Cigars usually contain 3 different types of tobacco, the filler, the binder and the wrapper. It's the combination of the three that gives each one it's individual taste. The green, or candola wrappers, were never to my taste. The brown, or natural wrappers are the most popular and usually give a mild flavor. My personal favorite is the madura, or black, wrapper. The taste is a bit more robust. Four countries product the majority of today's cigars, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Nicaragua and Hondorus. Cuban cigars are still banned in the US due to the Cuban embargo but I've had opportunities to smoke a few over the years. They tend to be strong and very robust. Ones from the Dominican Republic were always my favorites, with Hondorus next. Never cared much for the ones from Nicaragua. Most of the Dominican tobacco has been grown from seeds brought from Cuba and many of the Cuban manufacturers also manufacturer in the D.R. My all time favorite is the Arturo Fuente Churchill Maduro. Some others I enjoyed were Punch, CAO, H. Upmann, Macanudo (what Tony Sopranno smoked!), Hoyo de Monterrey and Partagas. For a new smoker like yourself, I would recommend the CAO or Upmann with a natural wrapper. They are milder than most of the others I've mentioned.

Cigars can get quite expensive. Mike's Cigars, http://www.mikescigars.com/brands-cigars/, sells a brand called Old Fashioned. These are seconds from some of the major manufacturers and are a lot cheaper. Most are seconds because of blemishes on the wrappers. Another good source is JR Cigars, http://www.jrcigars.com/jr/index.cfm. They are probably the biggest distributor in the country. Some of their house brands are very good and reasonably priced. I always found Mike's to be a bit cheaper on name brands than JR. Both sell sample packs which is a great way to sample different ones to find what you enjoy.

A humidor is a must have if you're serious about cigars. They will maintain them at the proper 70% relative humidity. All cigars are aged but will benefit from additional aging. Aging allows the binder, wrapper and filler to combine for a more even, flavorful smoke. Being the cheap bastard that I am, I built my own humidor from a Rubbermaid container. If you're interested I can give you the details.

Thanks for all the info, you've always been one to go out if your way with detail in a post and I appreciate that. I'm going to pick up a Maduro and Macanudo on my next visit. So far I've been drawn towards darker cigars for their aroma, and honestly they're more aesthetically appealing to me. Some of the lighter wrappers feel cheaper to me, like smoking a Dutch Master Palma, but that's my own stigma.
 
Great post. I've been known to indulge, specially before the vape arrived. I saw Macanudos at a Walgreens lately. Single torpedos in a foil bag for $8. I wasn't impressed after wasting $8. I prefer the Maduro too and agree the Dominicans are so far in the lead overall. From top line to rejects, which I buy in bulk if I like them. I visit a small shop with a smoking room. At the door they keep a barrel with assorted loose singles from all the bundles so sampling is easy and reasonable.
Recently I picked up a bundle from the Dominican Garcia house that had a special Band with their Initials that didn't show on their website up there with Monte Cristos and others. Thats unusual for rejects that normally have a generic or cutsey name like Cuban Rejects. The quality was there though, under $2 bulk.
I've had Cuban Cohibas and Monte's in Mexico, Netherlands, and US, not knock offs, and think the Dominicans are right up there.

I've been buying single factory seconds out of a jar as well.and have been rather happy with them so far. Around here they're about $2 a piece as well so I won't feel bad if there is one I hate and toss out.
 
I'm tired of seeing crazy prices for good cigars but settling for the cut rate too long, I decided to try buying long leaf quality materials to blend and roll my own with the help of You Tube videos.
Here is my first try.
Dominican binder
3 parts Piloto Cubano - Seco
1 part Criollo 1998 viso (aged from 1998)
Wrapper- Habano 2000 (aged from 2000)

index.php

No more "This contains man made materials" for me.
It drew smooth, tasted great, and the wife even said it smelled great rather than her normal "P. U. that stinks."​
 
  • Like
Reactions: gbd
Probably too late to respond to the original question, but if you like Arturo Fuente stuff (my favorite is the 8-5-8 Maduro), I'd check out some sticks from Padron. The Oliva Series "V" stuff is nice as well. Of course, if you want to get into forbidden territory (if you're in the States), I like the Romeo Y Julieta Short Churchills and the Partagas D4s.
 
Back
Top